More funding promised to men's behaviour change programs, but we're still not sure they work

In the wake of last week’s horrific murder of a woman and her three children in Brisbane at the hands of her estranged partner, Social Services Minister Anne Ruston announced A$2.4 million in fe...

Rebecca Stewart, Doctoral Candidate at BehaviourWorks Australia, Monash Sustainable Development Institute, Monash University - avatar Rebecca Stewart, Doctoral Candidate at BehaviourWorks Australia, Monash Sustainable Development Institute, Monash University

'It is quite startling': 4 photos from space that show Australia before and after the recent rain

National MapEditor’s note: These before-and-after-images from several sources –NASA’s Worldview application, National Map by Geoscience Australia and Digital Earth Australia – ...

Sunanda Creagh, Head of Digital Storytelling - avatar Sunanda Creagh, Head of Digital Storytelling

Bernie Sanders easily wins Nevada caucus; the Coalition regains support in Newspoll

LARRY W. SMITH/EPABernie Sanders has easily won the Nevada Democratic caucus, cementing his status as front-runner for the Democratic nomination in the US presidential election. With 88% of precincts...

Adrian Beaumont, Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Melbourne - avatar Adrian Beaumont, Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Melbourne

This time is different: Australia's tourist numbers may take years to recover

Australia’s catastrophic bushfire season has done immense damage to Australia’s tourist industry. Then, just as heavy rain began to bring the situation under control, came the coronavirus ...

John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland - avatar John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland

We won't have fusion generators in five years. But the holy grail of clean energy may still be on its way

CCFE / JETRecent reports from scientists pursuing a new kind of nuclear fusion technology are encouraging, but we are still some distance away from the “holy grail of clean energy”. The te...

Matthew Hole, Senior Research Fellow, Mathematical Sciences Institute, Australian National University - avatar Matthew Hole, Senior Research Fellow, Mathematical Sciences Institute, Australian National University

Labor’s climate policy is too little, too late. We must run faster to win the race

Opposition leader Anthony Albanese’s announcement on Friday that a Labor government would adopt a target of net-zero emissions by 2050 was a big step in the right direction. But a bit of simple ...

Will Steffen, Emeritus Professor, Australian National University - avatar Will Steffen, Emeritus Professor, Australian National University

Burnt is out, 'skinscreen' is in. How sunscreen got a beauty makeover

Instagram/#CalltimeonmelanomaUnder Australia’s harsh sun, we’ve long slapped on sunscreen to protect ourselves from skin damage and cancer. Now the product, once known for protecting skin ...

Lauren Gurrieri, Senior Lecturer in Marketing, RMIT University - avatar Lauren Gurrieri, Senior Lecturer in Marketing, RMIT University

I think my child has outgrown their food allergy. How can I be sure?

ShutterstockSome children grow out of their food allergies, but researchers don’t exactly know why.Here’s how to work with your allergy specialist if you suspect your child isn’t all...

Paxton Loke, Paediatric Allergist and Immunologist, Murdoch Children's Research Institute - avatar Paxton Loke, Paediatric Allergist and Immunologist, Murdoch Children's Research Institute

More than 70% of the Universe is made of 'dark energy', the mysterious stuff even stranger than dark matter

ShutterstockYou’ve heard of dark matter. You’ve probably heard there’s a fair bit of it out there in space, and that astronomers don’t know for sure what it is. But, strange as...

Sunanda Creagh, Head of Digital Storytelling - avatar Sunanda Creagh, Head of Digital Storytelling

Eating disorders are about emotional pain – not food

Taylor Swift, one of millions of Americans who has struggled with an eating disorder.AP Images/Invision/Charles SykesIn her documentary “Miss Americana,” music icon Taylor Swift disclosed ...

Michele Patterson Ford, Lecturer in Psychology, Dickinson College - avatar Michele Patterson Ford, Lecturer in Psychology, Dickinson College

College men more likely to seek grade changes than college women

If you don't ask for a higher grade you won't get one.ONOKY-Eric Audras/Getty Images“Professor, my final grade in your class is a C. Is there anything I can do to get a B-minus?”In my job ...

Cher Li, Assistant Professor of Economics, Colorado State University - avatar Cher Li, Assistant Professor of Economics, Colorado State University

Why some of the best-known tunes, like 'Happy Birthday,' are the hardest to sing

If the range of a song is good for you, you're much more likely to enjoy and find ease in singing it.Image Source/Getty ImagesSome friends and I recently went to karaoke. You can likely picture the sc...

Bryan Nichols, Assistant Professor of Music, Pennsylvania State University - avatar Bryan Nichols, Assistant Professor of Music, Pennsylvania State University

Goldman Sachs' push for board diversity doesn't go far enough

U.S. corporate boards still lack women.Rawpixel.com/Shutterstock.comSeveral European countries – including Norway, Germany, Finland, France and Spain – have introduced quotas for women on ...

Christy Glass, Professor of Sociology, Utah State University - avatar Christy Glass, Professor of Sociology, Utah State University

Indian women protest new citizenship laws, joining a global 'fourth wave' feminist movement

Women in Delhi's Shaheen Bagh neighborhood are protesting a new Indian citizenship law that they say will discriminate against Muslims, women – and, particularly, Muslim women.Burhaan Kinu/Hindu...

Alka Kurian, Senior Lecturer, School of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences, University of Washington, Bothell - avatar Alka Kurian, Senior Lecturer, School of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences, University of Washington, Bothell

Most Australians are spending more of their income on housing than they used to, but low-income households are being squeezed the hardest.

Many are in poverty, and many more are suffering financial stress. A growing number of Australians are becoming homeless.

A decade ago the Rudd federal government established the National Rental Affordability Scheme – NRAS. The scheme paid incentives to developers and community housing organisations that built new homes and rented them out for at least 20% below market rents for 10 years.

The Abbott government axed the scheme in 2014. Labor promised to reintroduce it if won the 2019 election. Now advocates of affordable housing are calling on the Morrison government to do the same.

But new research published by the Grattan Institute today concludes they are wrong. The NRAS was expensive, inefficient and mainly helped those not in greatest need.

Read more: On housing, there's clear blue water between the main parties

Other policies, such as building social housing and boosting Commonwealth Rent Assistance, would be better targeted and waste less money along the way.

Poor value for money

The value of the NRAS subsidy was set much higher than it needed to be.

NRAS developers still on the program receive about A$11,000 of public money per unit per year (the subsidy was set originally at A$8,000, but indexed).

The problem is, A$11,000 is much more money than the developers need to cover the cost of the rental discount.

In 2016 the value of the 20% rental discount was slightly less than A$4,000 a year in the typical suburb in which NRAS properties were built.

Read more: Ten lessons from cities that have risen to the affordable housing challenge

The leftover value of the subsidy – about A$7,000 a year – was essentially a windfall gain for developers.

We estimate it provided windfall gains to private developers of at least A$1 billion, or roughly one-third of the total cost of the scheme.

Community housing providers also received windfall gains, although they would have reinvested the funds into more affordable housing or deeper rental discounts for tenants.

The scheme was also poor value for money because the subsidy didn’t vary depending on location or type of dwelling: the same subsidy was offered for a one-bedroom apartment or a three-bedroom home. Not surprisingly, the scheme ultimately funded a lot of small, cheap-to-build units.

Not directed at those most in need

The eligibility criteria were far too loose.

Someone can qualify to live in one of the NRAS dwellings left on the scheme with an income of up to A$50,000 – a good deal higher than the median income.

A couple can qualify if their household income is below A$70,000.

It means about half of all households that rent can qualify to live in an NRAS subsidised home. Half of them would be ineligible for Commonwealth Rent Assistance because their incomes are too high.

Only one-third of the households living in an NRAS home at the scheme’s peak in 2016 had gross household incomes below A$30,000 a year, whereas one-third had incomes above A$50,000 a year.

No extra housing

There’s also little evidence the NRAS led to much more housing being built than otherwise.

Government subsidies don’t create extra housing if they crowd out housing that would have been built anyway. Crowding out is most likely when supply is already constrained, as it is in major Australian cities where land-use rules prevent greater density in established suburbs. International research suggests affordable housing crowds out private housing.

No useful stimulus

Nor was the NRAS a useful stimulus. It began in 2008 at the height of the global financial crisis, but most NRAS properties were only approved between 2013 and 2015, by which time housing construction was already booming.

Administrative difficulties and a complex design made housing constructed through NRAS anything but timely.

Better alternatives

Instead of reinstating the NRAS, state and federal governments should focus on policies that will do the most (at least cost) to better house low-income Australians.

A Rudd-era policy the Morrison government should introduce is the Social Housing Initiative, which built 20,000 new social housing units and refurbished another 80,000 over two years at a cost of A$5.6 billion.

The economic hit was immediate: construction approvals spiked within 12 months of the announcement. A repeat today would provide a more effective boost to declining housing construction than a reinstated NRAS.

Read more: Australia's social housing policy needs stronger leadership and an investment overhaul

Boosting Commonwealth Rent Assistance by 40%, and indexing it to changes in rents typically paid by people receiving income support, would be a fairer and more cost-effective way to help the much larger number of lower-income earners struggling with housing costs.

It shouldn’t push up rents much because only some of the extra assistance will be spent on housing.

The states should also fix planning rules that prevent more homes being built in inner and middle-ring suburbs of our largest cities. It would help a bit to make housing cheaper to buy and rent. Reforming tenancy rules would make renting more secure.

Read more: To make housing more affordable this is what state governments need to do

There is a powerful case for governments to do more to help house low-income Australians. But unless we learn from past mistakes, we will wind up with another expensive housing policy that does little to help those who most need that support.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/rudds-rental-affordability-scheme-was-a-1-billion-gift-to-developers-abbott-was-right-to-axe-it-122854