Is a Home Inspection Required When Buying a House?

Inspecting anything before you complete a purchase is a good idea. For example, you can use a magnetic particle testing device to check that the metal surface is free from defects. Or, you can have ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Trump Remembers the Forgotten

Not so long ago Washington all but gave up on our country’s blue-collar workers.  They washed their hands of those in the supposedly outdated manufacturing and energy sectors.  The message the perpe...

Dr. Robert Owens - avatar Dr. Robert Owens

As weary Britons head to the polls again, parties seem incapable of handling the nation's problems

The cost of running the 2017 UK general election was estimated at £140 million (A$270 million). It’s likely to be higher this time. In 2017, the Conservatives, Labour and the Liberal Democ...

Rob Manwaring, Senior Lecturer, Politics and Public Policy, Flinders University - avatar Rob Manwaring, Senior Lecturer, Politics and Public Policy, Flinders University

I had an idea in the 1980s and to my surprise, it changed education around the world

Cogitive load theory explains why explicit guidance from teachers is more effective in teaching students new content and skills than letting them discover these for themselves.from shutterstock.comThi...

John Sweller, Emeritus Professor, UNSW - avatar John Sweller, Emeritus Professor, UNSW

Indonesian cave paintings show the dawn of imaginative art and human spiritual belief

This hunting scene, painted 44,000 years ago, is the oldest known work of representational art in the world.Ratno Sardi, Author providedOur team has discovered a cave painting in Indonesia that is at ...

Adam Brumm, ARC Future Fellow, Griffith University - avatar Adam Brumm, ARC Future Fellow, Griffith University

As simple as finding a job? Getting people out of social housing is much more complex than that

A private member’s bill, moved by Labor MP Josh Burns, recently called on the Australian government “to help build more affordable homes” in response to the growing homelessness cri...

Chris Hartley, Research Fellow (Housing and Homelessness) at the Centre for Social Impact, UNSW - avatar Chris Hartley, Research Fellow (Housing and Homelessness) at the Centre for Social Impact, UNSW

Marianne Leonard: a new film tells us little about the woman fixed in the role of musician's muse

Marianne Ihlen: she remains stuck in the role of the beautiful ingénue, the part-time lover, in Nick Broomfield's documentary.Copyright Nick BroomfieldNick Broomfield’s latest documentary...

Tanya Dalziell, Associate Professor, English and Literary Studies, University of Western Australia - avatar Tanya Dalziell, Associate Professor, English and Literary Studies, University of Western Australia

What limits shareholder activism as a force for good: the free-rider problem

Shareholder activism involves directly engaging with directors and executives of companies to effect change.www.shutterstock.comThe board of Australia’s second-biggest bank is in for some stick ...

Salvatore Ferraro, PhD candidate, RMIT University - avatar Salvatore Ferraro, PhD candidate, RMIT University

How New Zealanders miss out on hundreds of thousands in retirement savings

New Zealanders pay higher fees for KiwiSaver funds than people elsewhere.from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDIn the 12 years since New Zealand introduced the retirement fund KiwiSaver, nearly three mil...

Ayesha Scott, Senior Lecturer - Finance, Auckland University of Technology - avatar Ayesha Scott, Senior Lecturer - Finance, Auckland University of Technology

Diabetes and pregnancy can be a tricky (but achievable) mix: 6 things to think about if you want a baby and 1 if you don't

A successful pregnancy if you have diabetes comes down to planning and making sure you have the right health-care team behind you.from www.shutterstock.comThe number of people with diabetes is expecte...

Freya MacMillan, Senior Lecturer in Interprofessional Health Science, Western Sydney University - avatar Freya MacMillan, Senior Lecturer in Interprofessional Health Science, Western Sydney University

Examining how primates make vowel sounds pushes timeline for speech evolution back by 27 million years

Baboons make sounds, but how does it relate to human speech?Creative Wrights/Shutterstock.comSound doesn’t fossilize. Language doesn’t either.Even when writing systems have developed, they...

Thomas R. Sawallis, Visiting Scholar in New College, University of Alabama - avatar Thomas R. Sawallis, Visiting Scholar in New College, University of Alabama

What limits shareholder activism as a force for good: the free-rider problem

Shareholder activism involves directly engaging with directors and executives of companies to effect change.www.shutterstock.comThe board of Australia’s second-biggest bank is in for some stick ...

The Conversation - avatar The Conversation

How New Zealanders miss out on hundreds of thousands in retirement savings

New Zealanders pay higher fees for KiwiSaver funds than people elsewhere.from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDIn the 12 years since New Zealand introduced the retirement fund KiwiSaver, nearly three mil...

The Conversation - avatar The Conversation

USMCA: The 3 most important changes in the new NAFTA and why they matter

Pena Nieto, Trump and Trudeau signed the USCMA in November 2018.AP Photo/Pablo Martinez MonsivaisPresident Donald Trump and Democratic leaders agreed on a deal to pass a new trade agreement between th...

Amanda M. Countryman, Associate Professor of Agricultural Economics, Colorado State University - avatar Amanda M. Countryman, Associate Professor of Agricultural Economics, Colorado State University

Money laundering rarely gets as literal as the case in Thailand last week, where police raided homes of a ring suspected of laundering a billion baht (about A$48 million) of drug proceeds and found millions stashed in a washing machine.

Stories about money laundering, and efforts to prevent it, are rife.

In just the past week there were reports about Swiss bank UBS agreeing to pay a €10 million (about A$16 million) penalty to end an Italian money laundering case; a New Zealand company, Jin Yuan Finance, being fined NZ$4 million (about A$3.7 million) for not complying with anti-money laundering laws; and calls in Australia for a royal commission after leaked CCTV footage from Melbourne’s Crown Casino showed a man in a tracksuit exchanging “bricks of cash” worth hundreds of thousands of dollars for gaming chips in one of the casino’s high-roller rooms.

Read more: The Crown allegations show the repeated failures of our gambling regulators

In the latter case, Crown Casino defended itself on the basis of having a “comprehensive” Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing program overseen by the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC). But federal parliamentarian Andrew Wilkie called the situation a catastrophic “multinational, multi-jurisdictional and multi-agency” failure by politicians, state regulators, police and AUSTRAC.

He’s right, at least in part.

The deeper problem isn’t that national anti-money laundering laws are being flouted. It’s that the global anti-money laundering system is a failed experiment.

We need to have an honest conversation about what’s wrong with it, including the possibility that much of it is a waste of time, and some of it might be doing more harm than good.

99% design failure

Don’t get me wrong: money laundering controls do good things too. Suspicious transactions trigger alerts, offenders are arrested and assets seized.

But the amount of criminal funds intercepted is scarcely a drop in the bucket. The system is designed to catch some criminals. It has almost no impact on crime.

The United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime has estimated that just 0.2% of the proceeds of crime are seized. My update of the UN’s estimate (in research not yet published) suggests the figure might now be 0.1% or less. Either way, in practical terms the “success rate” of money laundering controls is scarcely an accounting rounding error in criminal accounts.

There are many reasons for anti-money laundering’s failure, but a big problem is the emphasis on activity and effort rather than results. It’s the same mindset that focuses on the number of hours spent at work rather than what’s achieved, or how many speeding tickets are issued instead of whether harm from accidents is reduced.

Reforms to the global anti-money laundering system, rolled out from 2014, were meant to address this problem. They didn’t. Though the language of “outcomes” and “effectiveness” was used, it meant something different to the impact and effect of regulations on reducing crime and its harms.

In other words, the new measures were mislabelled “outcomes”. They continued to measure effort and activity, such as the number of money laundering prosecutions, instead of the impact (if any) on crime. (I explain this in detail in a paper in the Journal of Money Laundering Control, freely available until January 2020).

Frenetic activity

Frenetic compliance activity helps obscure the harsh reality of poor results. Casinos and banks conform to complex rules designed like a giant stack of colanders to catch water, continually adding new ones to “fix gaps”. New “compliance solutions” doggedly rake over the same ground covered by those that catch less than 1% of transactions.

The upshot is that companies can show they comply with anti-money laundering laws (Crown’s response is straight out of the compliance textbook) and countries can show they comply with international standards.

But does it stop crime? Who knows? The system isn’t designed to demonstrate its impact on crime. Jin Yuan Finance, for example, was fined because it breached anti-money laundering laws, not because there was necessarily laundering or any other crime.

A criminal mastermind given the chance to rewrite anti-money laundering rules might just keep what we have, on the basis it keeps the authorities ineffectually busy.

Good intentions and ‘voluntary coercion’

The problems with the system can be traced to the rushed and flawed way it was set up.

The modern anti-money laundering experiment started in 1989, at a G7 summit in Paris. The seven big industrialised nations bypassed treaty-based consensus to establish a “Financial Action Task Force” to help prevent drug trafficking. The task force – known as FATF – later targeted money laundering associated with other profit-motivated crimes and terrorism financing.

After a sluggish start, with few nations signing up to its compliance model, FATF made an offer governments couldn’t refuse – ironically echoing a famous line from The Godfather.

FATF rated countries’ anti-money laundering regimes and issued “black lists” and “grey lists” publicly naming those not meeting its “recommendations”. Banks did the rest. Treating the ratings and lists as a proxy for risk, access to the financial system became difficult for many countries. FATF’s intention (in its own words) was to “pressure” countries to comply, “to maintain their position in the global economy”.

Risking exclusion from financial markets, 205 countries and jurisdictions “voluntarily” joined the anti-money laundering movement. The system depends on a set of self-declared “best-practice” standards. This means each national anti-money laundering regime reflects the flaws of the international standard.

Read more: With increased anti-money laundering measures, banks are shutting out women

At the UN General Assembly last month, leaders from small and large countries railed against the perceived unfairness and damage caused by blacklists and financial sanctions.

Such protests might be more easily dismissed as self-serving if the anti-money laundering system worked. But it doesn’t.

Complicated laws, armies of regulators and costly compliance tasks give the comfort of activity and feeling of security, but they don’t make us safe from serious crime and terrorism. To resolve it, we must frankly confront the reality of its failure.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/a-criminal-asked-to-design-our-anti-money-laundering-laws-would-probably-keep-the-ones-weve-got-125143