Australian economists overwhelmingly back social distancing measures that slow the spread of coronavirus over the alternative of easing restrictions and allowing the spread of the disease to pick up.

But a significant minority, 9 of the 47 leading economists polled in the first of a series of monthly surveys, say they would support an easing of restrictions even if it did allow the spread to accelerate.

The Economic Society of Australia-Conversation monthly poll will build on national polls conducted by the Economic Society, initially in conjunction with Monash University, since 2015.

The economists chosen to take part are Australia’s leaders in fields including microeconomics, macroeconomics, economic modelling and public policy. Among them are former and current government advisers and a former and current member of the Reserve Bank board.

Their responses are given weight by statements explaining their views published in full on The Conversation website and by a requirement that they rank the confidence they have in their responses on a scale of 1 to 10.

What matters is R

R, which is also referred to as R0, R₀, and Rt is the reproduction number of the virus. It a measure of the average number of other people that any person with it will directly infect.

The Conversation, CC BY-ND An R of 2 means that on average each person with the virus will directly infect two other people in a process that will escalate increasingly quickly until after four sets of contacts 16 people have it, and after 20 sets of contacts more than one million people have it. This snowballing effect is a property of any R above 1. At an R below 1 the spread decelerates until very few people have it. In the early days of the outbreaks, Australia’s value of R was well above 1. The lockdowns and other restrictions have helped push it down to about 1. The 47 leading Australian economists selected by the Economic Society of Australia were asked whether they agreed, disagreed, or strongly agreed or strongly disagreed with this proposition: The benefits to Australian society of maintaining social distancing measures sufficient to keep R less than 1 for COVID-19 are likely to exceed the costs. The proposition suggests that in the present context it is likely to be worthwhile to continue to maintain the restrictions that are needed to push R below 1 and keep it there. Almost three quarters of the economists surveyed – 34 out of 47 – backed the proposition, 23 of them “strongly”. Only nine disagreed, and only one strongly. The Conversation, CC BY-ND The arguments put for the worth of maintaining social distancing measures sufficient to keep R below 1 include avoiding “tens or hundreds of thousands of avoidable deaths” (John Quiggin) and allowing the economy to return to normal sooner than otherwise by escaping the need for “repeated lockdowns” that might be needed if the disease got out of control again (Ian Harper). Chris Edmond uses the analogy of the Phillips Curve that is meant to show the the tradeoff between levels of inflation and unemployment. Although it shows a tradeoff in the short term (more inflation results in lower unemployment) in the longer term it finds no such tradeoff. More inflation simply leads to higher prices with unemployment being no lower. Read more: Eradicating the COVID-19 coronavirus is also the best economic strategy “In a similar way, there is no long-run trade off between public health and the health of the economy in responding to the COVID-19 crisis,” he says. Lifting restrictions “risks the worst of all worlds, compromising our public health goals and at the same time not getting a proper economic recovery”. Stefanie Schurer quotes a German proverb: better a painful ending than an endless pain. Lifting restrictions “worst of all worlds” She says a short and medium term failure to eliminate, or at least slow down, the spread of COVID-19 would entail significant longer-run political, economic and social costs. Renee Fry-McKibbin points out that that even if the deaths from reopening economic activity turn out not to be high, we have no idea yet of the long term health consequences of exposing more people to COVID-19. “Will people suffer from respiratory issues going forward requiring ongoing medical attention?” she asks. “We have incomplete information on the actual costs and benefits.” Saul Eslake, who can see the worth of continued restrictions that keep R below 1, cautions that the longer they remain in place, the more the case for reopening will grow. Yet the costs of restrictions are growing Craig Emerson says keeping R below 1 should be merely a “guiding principle” rather than a binding constraint. “The longer the restrictions are in place, the greater will be the likelihood of links being broken - leading to severe economic hardship, business failures, mortgage defaults, domestic violence, mental health problems, suicide and long-term unemployment, particularly for the young,” he says. Gigi Foster says, in retrospect, the best thing for Australia to have done would have been to have never had an enforced lockdown, but to have encouraged people to continue to behave as normally as possible while taking precautions, as in Sweden, allowing young and healthy people to acquire immunity in order to protect more vulnerable people, in this and in future waves of the virus. She suspects the costs of continued restrictions that keep R below 1 outweigh the benefits, including benefits measured in quality-adjusted life years saved. Read more: COVID lockdowns have human costs as well as benefits. It's time to consider both Hugh Sibley says that by making progress towards eliminating the virus we have eliminated the option of acquiring the mass immunity that would make it easier to live with it. “We have, in effect, dug ourselves into a hole,” he says. “And we are now congratulating ourselves how deep that hole is. Too few people are asking how we get out.” Supporters more certain than opponents When responses to the survey are weighted by the confidence respondents have in them, opposition to restrictions weakens. Unweighted for confidence, 19% of respondents oppose the proposition that restrictions that keep R below 1 are likely to be value for money. Weighted for (lack of) confidence, opposition falls to 15.4%. The Conversation, CC BY-ND Unweighted for confidence, 72.3% support the proposition that restrictions that keep R below 1 are likely to be value for money. Weighted for confidence, that support grows to 77.1% The proportion strongly agreeing with the proposition grows from 48.9% to 54.8% Put another way, when weighted for confidence, a clear majority of the economists surveyed strongly support the proposition that the benefits to society from maintaining social distancing measures sufficient to keep R less than 1 are likely to exceed the costs. Individual responses

Authors: The Conversation

Read more https://theconversation.com/economists-back-social-distancing-34-9-in-new-economic-society-conversation-survey-138721

How Much Should I Borrow for My Study Lo…

There’s no doubt that study can open a lot of doors, many of which can lead to considerable success. Whether it be time to change your career, a desire to...

Keeping Your Commercial Premises Safe and Secure

When you run a small business, you take a lot of responsibility on your shoulders. But one of the most important areas to focus on is making sure that your commercial premises are safe and secur...

News Company - avatar News Company

Most Popular Ways To Send Money Internationally in 2020

What are the customers’ choice and cheapest ways for overseas payments Learn about different methods for sending money overseas. What features are important to you? Cheap or fast transfers? Which p...

News Company - avatar News Company

Most Popular Ways To Send Money Internationally in 2020

What are the customers’ choice and cheapest ways for overseas payments Learn about different methods for sending money overseas. What features are important to you? Cheap or fast transfers? Which p...

News Company - avatar News Company

Most Popular Ways To Send Money Internationally in 2020

What are the customers’ choice and cheapest ways for overseas payments Learn about different methods for sending money overseas. What features are important to you? Cheap or fast transfers? Which p...

News Company - avatar News Company

Most Popular Ways To Send Money Internationally in 2020

What are the customers’ choice and cheapest ways for overseas payments Learn about different methods for sending money overseas. What features are important to you? Cheap or fast transfers? Which p...

News Company - avatar News Company

Steps to Take if You Want to Use an MBA to Become an Entrepreneur

Becoming an entrepreneur can be done at any time, the catch is that it cannot be successfully done at any time. You need to have the expertise, the winning business idea, the financial backing, ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Surprising New Uses for Your Self Storage Unit

Among the most common ways to use a self storage unit are for holding valuables or for keeping items that you’re not ready to part with quite yet. But there are many other great uses that you mi...

News Company - avatar News Company

Could a Caravan Be a Good Investment for Your Holidays?

When we think of holidays and getaways, we generally tend to think of jumping on a plane and jetting off overseas. We head to all inclusive resorts, where we can kick back and relax on a sunloun...

News Company - avatar News Company

Four Tips When Job Hunting

Job hunting is something many of us will have to do for a number of times within our life. It can certainly be something that’s nerve-racking to go through, especially if it’s nothing something you’ve...

News Company - avatar News Company

Common Carpet problems and how to Fix Them

It can be difficult to pick the right type of flooring for your home. Timber and tile are popular choices, especially in areas where there is heavy track or chances of things being spilled. But...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Benefits of Vegan Protein Powder for Women

Most women steer away from protein shakes, so they don’t gain noticeable muscles, they would like to avoid any unnecessary calorie intake, or they don’t think they need lots of protein in their di...

Emily Stuart - avatar Emily Stuart

How to Affordably Makeover Your Property

Every homeowner will want to live in a beautiful property. However, outdated décor and worn furnishings can detract from your home’s interior design. If you dread the thought of spending time in you...

News Company - avatar News Company

Economists back social distancing 34-9 in new Economic Society-Conversation survey

Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-NDAustralian economists overwhelmingly back social distancing measures that slow the spread of coronavirus over the alternative of easing restrictions and allowing...

Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University - avatar Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Just how hot will it get this century? Latest climate models suggest it could be worse than we thought

Climate scientists use mathematical models to project the Earth’s future under a warming world, but a group of the latest models have included unexpectedly high values for a measure called &ldqu...

Michael Grose, Climate Projections Scientist, CSIRO - avatar Michael Grose, Climate Projections Scientist, CSIRO

Self-employed Australians' hours have fallen 32% since coronavirus hit – double the impact on all employees

ShutterstockAustralia Bureau of Statistics data has confirmed the massive economic hit from the COVID-19 pandemic, with total hours worked across the economy officially falling 9% between early March ...

Matthew Gray, Director, ANU Centre for Social Research and Methods, Australian National University - avatar Matthew Gray, Director, ANU Centre for Social Research and Methods, Australian National University

The trade-offs 'smart city' apps like COVIDSafe ask us to make go well beyond privacy

The Commonwealth government says if enough of us download its COVIDSafe app, restrictions on our movements and activities can be lifted more quickly and life can return to normal. As important as it i...

Kurt Iveson, Associate Professor of Urban Geography and Research Lead, Sydney Policy Lab, University of Sydney - avatar Kurt Iveson, Associate Professor of Urban Geography and Research Lead, Sydney Policy Lab, University of Sydney

Supermarkets claim to have our health at heart. But their marketing tactics push junk foods

ShutterstockSupermarkets like to portray themselves as having the health of the community at heart. And in the middle of a pandemic, we’re all grateful supermarkets are still open and, for the m...

Gary Sacks, Associate Professor, Deakin University - avatar Gary Sacks, Associate Professor, Deakin University