The Australian government is planning to spend A$190 billion to support the economy in response to COVID-19, according to the latest Parliamentary Budget Office estimate.

The total impact of COVID-19 on the government’s net debt, including both revenue impacts (down, because of less activity) and spending impacts (up because of spending to support the economy) amounts to between 11% and 18% of gross domestic product, or A$500 billion to A$620 billion.

image Parliamentary Budget Office The estimates are based on the three possible scenarios developed by the Reserve Bank: “downside”, “baseline” and “upside”. Each differ in their assumed timing of the relaxation of social distancing and other restrictions, and for how long uncertainty and diminished confidence weigh on households and business activity. With similar blow-outs around the world, a view gaining ascendancy, including amongst commentators such as Alan Kohler, is that government debt doesn’t matter – provided the government owes the money to its central bank (in Australia’s case, the Reserve Bank) or the bank is prepared to buy the debt from the party the government borrowed the money from. The view is an application of so-called modern monetary theory and the argument goes like this: when the government runs a budget deficit, it borrows from the private sector (mainly financial institutions) by selling government bonds which are effectively IOUs offering to repay in a certain number of years and offering interest at a low bond rate until then the Reserve Bank (along with other central banks) has been buying bonds from the private sector with money it creates, and says it is prepared to buy as many as are needed to keep the bond yield low, so that if it looks as if the bond rate will rise, much of the debt will ultimately be owed to the bank when the bonds expire and it is time to repay the debt, the government can simply issue more bonds which the bank will ultimately buy if it has to in order to keep the bond rate low if down the track all of the extra money in the banking system causes inflation, the process would be thrown into reverse: the government can the deficit, repay the Reserve Bank and others when loans fall due and cut the supply of money, slowing down inflation. It sounds too good to be true, because it is. There are a number of reasons why deficits and debt do matter, even if the debt is effectively owed to the central bank and even if it has been created in a recession, or in anticipation of one – as is the case for the COVID-19 response. Creating money carries risks We know that governments with high debt face interest rate premiums from lenders. A European Union study found that a 10 percentage point increase in the government debt to GDP ratio increased the sovereign bond rate by 0.47 percentage points. These higher risk premia flow on to private sector borrowers whose interest rates are set in relation to sovereign interest rates, so all households and businesses face higher rates. The result will be less investment and household spending than there would otherwise be. An attempt by the central bank to negate the risk premium by buying more bonds would allow the government to issue even more bonds, increasing the risk of inflation which would itself put upward pressure on interest rates. Read more: Explainer: what is modern monetary theory? The experience of Latin American countries that relied on their central banks to create money is frightening. Argentina and Venezuela in particular experienced inflation rates of up to 50% and plummeting exchange rates. The idea that, if and when inflation arrives, the Australian government could easily throw its spending and tax engines into reverse is fanciful. It is politically difficult to wind back government spending and raise taxes. To do so on a large scale might be impossible. Modern Monetary theorists respond by pointing out that we have not yet seen inflation in Western countries that have pumped up their money supplies. That’s true, but while the government has been running up debt, we have seen inflation of a sort in big increases in asset prices in housing and stock markets. It has made us more vulnerable to financial shocks and priced many first home buyers out of the market. Markets aren’t forgiving image Markets aren’t always forgiving. And what if the foreign exchange market does not buy the modern monetary theory story? Even the expectation of future inflation by the market, before it arrives, could lead to a depreciation of the Australian dollar which could itself create inflation which would make Australians poorer. A final point: the Reserve Bank of Australia is independent from the government. If confidence in this independence was eroded, we could see an increase in perceived risk of holding Australian financial assets. This in turn would cause higher interest rates and a lower Australian dollar. In any case, the Reserve Bank might decide at some point that the risk of inflation or asset price inflation is unacceptable and refuse to buy more government bonds, or sell back to the private sector the bonds it’s bought. Read more: Vital Signs. Do deficits matter any more? This would mean the government debt was owed to the private sector once again. Financial markets might view it as more risky than debt owed to the bank, with negative consequences for interest rates and the exchange rate. I am inclined to agree with the International Monetary Fund’s chief economist who said in relation to modern monetary theory before the COVID crisis that there was “no free lunch”. Martin Wolf of the Financial Times said during the crisis that modern monetary theory was both right and wrong. It was right, because there is no simple budget constraint. It was wrong, because it would prove impossible to manage the economy sensibly once politicians believed there was no simple budget constraint.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-spending-splurge-matters-regardless-of-what-modern-monetary-theory-says-137241

Cyberspace is critical infrastructure – it will take effective government oversight to make it safe

Cyberspace has become indispensable during the COVID-19 pandemic, heightening the need for online protections.Ariel Skelley/DigitalVision via Getty ImagesA famous 1990s New Yorker cartoon showed two dogs at a computer and...

¿Por qué algunos estadounidenses parecen más 'estadounidenses' que otros?

Las nobles nociones igualitarias sobre la ciudadanía no siempre se sostienenAP Photo/Charlie NeibergallEn Estados Unidos y en muchos otros países, la nacionalidad se define por un conjun...

Katherine Kinzler, Professor of Psychology, University of Chicago - avatar Katherine Kinzler, Professor of Psychology, University of Chicago

Controversias en la investigación del coronavirus muestran que la ciencia está funcionando como debería

Un paper de alto perfil sobre los riesgos del medicamento antimalárico hidroxicloriquina fue retirado en junio.AP Photo/John Locher,Varios artículos de alto perfil sobre la investigaci&o...

Mark R. O'Brian, Professor and Chair of Biochemistry, Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York - avatar Mark R. O'Brian, Professor and Chair of Biochemistry, Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York

How COVID-19 might increase risk of memory loss and cognitive decline

More and more studies are revealing the cognitive effects of COVID-19.Amornrat Phuchom / Getty ImagesOf all frightening ways that the SARS-COV-2 virus affects the body, one of the more insidious is th...

Natalie C. Tronson, Associate Professor of Psychology, University of Michigan - avatar Natalie C. Tronson, Associate Professor of Psychology, University of Michigan

Why New York is suing the NRA: 4 questions answered

The suit alleges improprieties by Wayne LaPierre and other current and former NRA officials. Scott Olson/Getty ImagesEditor’s note: New York state Attorney General Letitia James is suing the Na...

Brian Mittendorf, Fisher Designated Professor of Accounting, The Ohio State University - avatar Brian Mittendorf, Fisher Designated Professor of Accounting, The Ohio State University

Lost your job due to coronavirus? Artificial intelligence could be your best friend in finding a new one

Some places are still hiring.AP Photo/Lynne SladkyMillions of Americans are unemployed and looking for work. Hiring continues, but there’s far more demand for jobs than supply. As scholars of h...

Stewart Black, Professor of Management Practice in Global Leadership and Strategy, INSEAD - avatar Stewart Black, Professor of Management Practice in Global Leadership and Strategy, INSEAD