VIDEO: Michelle Grattan on the government's drought policy - and the trust divide in politics

Michelle Grattan says the announcement of extra money for drought-stricken farmers "won't be enough" to alleviate pressure on the government on the issue of drought. ShutterstockUniversity of Canberra...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Our ability to manufacture minerals could transform the gem market, medical industries and even help suck carbon from the air

Pictured is a slag pile at Broken Hill in New South Wales. Slag is a man-made waste product created during smelting. Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Author providedLast month, scientists uncovered a mineral call...

Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Senior Research Fellow in Geometallurgy/Applied Geochemistry, The University of Queensland - avatar Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Senior Research Fellow in Geometallurgy/Applied Geochemistry, The University of Queensland

Lambie stays mute on medevac vote after Senate inquiry splits on party lines

Jacqui Lambie has yet to announce whether she will support the bill to have medevac repealed.AAP/Mick TsikasThe Senate inquiry into repealing medevac has predictably split along party lines, with the ...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Sydney's 9,189 'sister politicians' who petitioned Queen Victoria

One spring morning in 1850, over 8,000 Sydneysiders marched through town to protest the resumption of transportation – the act of sending British criminals to Australia. It was the largest prote...

Kiera Lindsey, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Kiera Lindsey, University of Technology Sydney

Penny Whetton: A pioneering climate scientist skilled in the art of life

Penny Whetton, right, addressing a March for Science rally. Her death last month shocked and saddened colleagues.Supplied by familyLast month we lost Dr Penny Whetton - one of the world’s most r...

John M Clarke, Team Leader, Regional Projections, CSIRO - avatar John M Clarke, Team Leader, Regional Projections, CSIRO

​The Coalition government is (again) trying to put the squeeze on the ABC

The Coalition government has reintroduced a bill seeking to mandate the ABC devote more resources to covering regional Australia – a measure that has been defeated before by parliament.Danny Cas...

Fiona R Martin, Senior Lecturer in Convergent and Online Media, University of Sydney - avatar Fiona R Martin, Senior Lecturer in Convergent and Online Media, University of Sydney

Trump is flouting global trade rules with China yet embracing them with the EU – here's why it matters

Just as America’s trade war with China may be winding down, its troubles with Europe seem to be growing. On Oct. 11, President Donald Trump said that the United States and China had agreed, in p...

Charles Hankla, Associate Professor of Political Science, Georgia State University - avatar Charles Hankla, Associate Professor of Political Science, Georgia State University

Where is my Xanax Rx? Why your doctor may be concerned about prescribing benzodiazepines

Xanax, sold generically as alprazolam, is a popular drug to treat anxiety -- and to sell on the street.PureRadiancePhoto/Shutterstock.comAs an academic psychiatrist who treats people with anxiety and ...

Arash Javanbakht, Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, Wayne State University - avatar Arash Javanbakht, Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, Wayne State University

Blockchain voting is vulnerable to hackers, software glitches and bad ID photos – among other problems

How secure is online voting with blockchain technology?WhiteDragon/Shutterstock.comA developing technology called “blockchain” has gotten attention from election officials, startups and ev...

Nir Kshetri, Professor of Management, University of North Carolina – Greensboro - avatar Nir Kshetri, Professor of Management, University of North Carolina – Greensboro

Pope affirms Catholic Church's duty to indigenous Amazonians hurt by climate change

Pope Francis at the start of the Amazon synod, at the Vatican, Oct. 7, 2019.AP Photo/Andrew MedichiniThe Catholic Church “hears the cry” of the Amazon and its peoples. That’s the mes...

Vincent J. Miller, Professor of Religious Studies, University of Dayton - avatar Vincent J. Miller, Professor of Religious Studies, University of Dayton

How Mister Rogers' faith shaped his idea of children's television

Fred Rogers rehearses with some of his puppet friends in Pittsburgh,.Gene J. Puskarg/AP The beloved children’s television icon Fred Rogers – who is played by actor Tom Hanks in the upcomin...

L. Benjamin Rolsky, Adjunct Professor of History, Religion, and Anthropology, Monmouth University - avatar L. Benjamin Rolsky, Adjunct Professor of History, Religion, and Anthropology, Monmouth University

The Chicago teachers' strike isn't just about kids – it's about union power too

Chicago's teachers are on strike for the first time since 2012.AP Photo/Martha IrvineClasses in Chicago’s public schools were canceled starting Oct. 17 as more than 25,000 teachers in the nation...

Bradley D. Marianno, Assistant Professor of Educational Policy & Leadership, University of Nevada, Las Vegas - avatar Bradley D. Marianno, Assistant Professor of Educational Policy & Leadership, University of Nevada, Las Vegas

This overdose-reversal medicine could reduce opioid deaths – so why don't more people carry it?

Naloxone, available as a nasal spray called Narcan or in injectable form, resuscitates 100% of people who overdose if administered quickly. AP Photo/Patrick SemanskyForty-seven thousand Americans died...

Tarlise Townsend, Joint PhD Student, Health Policy and Sociology, University of Michigan - avatar Tarlise Townsend, Joint PhD Student, Health Policy and Sociology, University of Michigan

Here's what's missing in efforts to curb heavy drinking and hazing on campus

Colleges throughout the nation are beset with problems of alcohol and hazing on campus. AP Photo/Dake KangMaxwell Gruver had been a student at Louisiana State University for only a few weeks in 2017 b...

Adam M. McCready, Visiting Assistant Professor, Higher Education & Student Affairs, University of Connecticut - avatar Adam M. McCready, Visiting Assistant Professor, Higher Education & Student Affairs, University of Connecticut

imageResponses to small price signals may be more emotional than rational, but they're real. AAP Image/Dave Hunt

Amid last week’s furore over the on-again, off-again Medicare co-payment proposal, Prime Minister Tony Abbott emphasised during Question Time that his government wanted “to see price signals in the system” in relation to public health and Medicare.

The principle of price signals is a compelling one – it forces people to weigh the benefits they receive against the costs of the resources they are using. This helps prevent wasteful use of our national resources, which is what economic efficiency is all about.

That said, there is a fundamental flaw: in an essential health system such as Medicare, flat-charge price signals have the capacity to hurt most those who are least able to afford its services.

A recent survey assessed 47 international studies on the behavioural effects of co-payments for health care. It found low-income people in poor health reduced their use of health services proportionally more than others.

Australian daily life is littered with instances of seemingly minor imposts exerting a far greater influence on behaviour than anyone could possibly have imagined. Why would health care be any different?

The classic example in the lives of commuters is toll-avoidance. Melbourne and Sydney are full of rat-running and toll avoidance every day of the week. The average price of a single toll trip might be only A$3.30 but this affects lived behaviour profoundly. It does not necessarily force people out of cars into public transport, to car-pool, or to telecommute. But it does mean that intersections at either end of a toll road are jammed at peak hour.

Take another example: petrol dockets. For a discount of just four cents per litre, thousands of motorists will clip coupons and will drive out of their way to branded petrol stations that honour their discount vouchers. Is this rational? Based on an average tank capacity of 60 litres, the total saving is less than A$2.50. Many drivers spend much of that “discount” just driving to the station.

imageSome motorists go to extraordinary lengths to avoid tolls.TK Kurikawa/Shutterstock

So powerful was this “small price signal” that in February 2014 the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission took formal action against the two major supermarkets for apparently not adhering to a promise to limit their fuel docket values, since they were skewing buyer behaviour so dramatically. Since the co-branding regime began, the market shares of Coles Express and Woolworths Caltex have risen to claim over 48% of the petrol-purchasing public. Many independent operations have simply closed.

This may be more emotional behaviour than a rational response. But it is real, nonetheless.

And the list goes on: Many people get intensely upset over A$2.00 charges for baggage trolleys at the airport. They are irked when their mobile phones drop out in a transmission dead-zone and they have to ring a number again. The average cost of a re-dial? Less than 29 cents.

Toll evasion on public transport is a serious, ongoing issue. The average cost of a journey? Less than A$3.00.

Many businesses add 1% (or more) of the purchase cost solely because the customer is paying with a credit card. Another major grumble.

Many pensioners will ask businesses to please provide them with a landline number to ring, because the former is about 40% cheaper than a call to a mobile number. The average saving per phone call? Less than 20 cents.

In the real world, small and personal price signals really do matter. So the argument that a A$7 fee hike for GP visits will not affect behaviour in negative ways doesn’t hold.

As many medical peak bodies have already observed, the one certainty is that the most vulnerable members of the community will be the most adversely affected. Even more: that patients with less serious ailments will flood emergency departments of public hospitals instead – those same waiting rooms that are already filled to overflowing.

Levying a A$7 co-payment for everyone who fronts up at the doctor’s office — regardless of their means — is just asking for trouble. Order a blood test for cholesterol? Another A$7. Get an x-ray to make sure your back injury is muscular and not skeletal in nature? Ditto.

imageCo-payments disproportionately affect low-income groups.Grenville Turner/AAP Image

Discouraging people from seeing their GP is counter to all sensible trends in preventative medicine. For the past 30 years, every cogent public health campaign has emphasised the importance of early diagnosis (of skin and breast cancers, of asthma, of diabetes).

This is especially true in the case of Indigenous health campaigns. The uphill battle has been one of persuading First Nations people to trust and visit their GPs in the first place. Over the past six months, Aboriginal medical services across the country have slammed the co-payment idea for just that reason and have vowed not to charge it.

The biggest health insurers — including the recently privatised Medibank Private — have proven the worth of the preventative approach. Over the past decade, managing director George Savvides has overseen clever initiatives such as the adding of points to any Medibank subscriber’s Flybuys account if they buy fresh or frozen fruit and vegetables from Coles supermarkets.

Can anyone doubt the importance of small price-signalling there? Or the premise that a milligram of prevention is worth a kilogram of cure? This is being undermined by an inflexible Medicare co-payment proposition that refuses to die.

Finally, the stated motivation for the co-payment — which is to help repair the budget and contain health spending — has been undermined by splurging A$5 of the co-payment on a medical research fund. This is not to deny the importance of medical research — far from it. But why ask the poor and sick to bear a disproportionate burden of the cost?

This has to be looked at seriously. It has to be looked at now. The price-signalling evidence suggests that the Medicare co-payment proposal should be buried once and for all on the floor of the House of Representatives.

image

The authors do not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article. They also have no relevant affiliations.

Read more http://theconversation.com/real-life-decisions-why-price-signals-for-medicare-are-flawed-34851