NewsPronto

 
The Times


.

USA Conversation

The Conversation USA

The Conversation USA

What is peer review? The role anonymous experts play in scrutinizing research before it gets published

  • Written by Joshua Winowiecki, Assistant Professor of Nursing, Michigan State University

Reviewer 1: “This manuscript is a timely and important contribution to the field, with clear methodology and compelling results. I recommend publication with only minor revisions.”

Reviewer 2: “This manuscript is deeply flawed. The authors’ conclusions are not supported by data, and key literature is ignored. Major revisions...

Read more: What is peer review? The role anonymous experts play in scrutinizing research before it gets...

More Articles ...

  1. University students feel ‘anxious, confused and distrustful’ about AI in the classroom and among their peers
  2. Examining mushrooms under microscopes can help engineers design stronger materials
  3. What makes ‘great powers’ great? And how will they adapt to a multipolar world?
  4. California farmers identify a hot new cash crop: Solar power
  5. Angels, witches, crystals and black cats: How supernatural beliefs vary across different groups in the US
  6. China’s insertion into India-Pakistan waters dispute adds a further ripple in South Asia
  7. Trump free to begin gutting Department of Education after Supreme Court ‘shadow’ ruling − 5 essential reads
  8. Florida is fronting the $450M cost of Alligator Alcatraz – a legal scholar explains what we still don’t know about the detainees
  9. Rethinking the MBA: Character as the educational foundation for future business leaders
  10. Weird space weather seems to have influenced human behavior on Earth 41,000 years ago – our unusual scientific collaboration explores how
  11. Sculptor galaxy image provides brilliant details that will help astronomers study how stars form
  12. Many Texas communities are dangerously unprepared for floods − lack of funding plays a big role
  13. How universities can keep protests from turning violent: 3 lessons from the 2024 pro-Palestinian encampments
  14. Europe is stuck in a bystander role over Iran’s nuclear program after US, Israeli bombs establish facts on the ground
  15. How 17M Americans enrolled in Medicaid and ACA plans could lose their health insurance by 2034
  16. A law from the era of Red Scares is supercharging Trump administration’s power over immigrants and noncitizens
  17. News quiz text reminders
  18. ABC’s and CBS’s settlements with Trump are a dangerous step toward the commander in chief becoming the editor-in-chief
  19. Is there any hope for the internet?
  20. 2026 FIFA World Cup expansion will have a big climate footprint, with matches from Mexico to Canada – here’s what fans can do
  21. When big sports events like FIFA World Cup expand, their climate footprint expands too
  22. When big sports events expand, like FIFA’s 2026 World Cup matches across North America, their climate footprint expands too
  23. Listening to nonhumans: What music can teach about humanity’s relationships with nature and the divine
  24. Zohran Mamdani’s last name reflects centuries of intercontinental trade, migration and cultural exchange
  25. Trump’s Brazil tariffs point more to his enduring bond with far-right Bolsonaro than economic concerns
  26. Most Pennsylvania voters ignore judicial elections − a political scientist explains why they matter, especially in a battleground state
  27. Who was the first pirate?
  28. When disasters fall out of the public eye, survivors continue to suffer – a rehabilitation professional explains how sustained mental health support is critical to recovery
  29. FEMA’s flood maps often miss dangerous flash flood risks, leaving homeowners unprepared
  30. How citizenship chaos was averted, for now, by a class action injunction against Trump’s birthright citizenship order
  31. Why it can be hard to warn people about dangers like floods – communication researchers explain the role of human behavior
  32. IRS says churches may endorse political candidates despite a decades-old federal statute barring them from doing that
  33. Why do so many American workers feel guilty about taking the vacation they’ve earned?
  34. Inequality has risen from 1970 to Trump − that has 3 hidden costs that undermine democracy
  35. Spacecraft equipped with a solar sail could deliver earlier warnings of space weather threats to Earth’s technologies
  36. AI in health care could save lives and money − but change won’t happen overnight
  37. Muscle weakness in cancer survivors may be caused by treatable weakness in blood vessels – new research
  38. Spotted lanternflies love grapevines, and that’s bad for Pennsylvania’s wine industry
  39. School smartphone bans reflect growing concern over youth mental health and academic performance
  40. This tropical plant builds isolated ‘apartments’ to prevent battles among the aggressive ant tenants it relies on for survival
  41. Justice Department efforts to strip citizenship from naturalized Americans likely violate constitutional rights
  42. Trump’s ‘big’ bill gives millions of taxpayers a new charitable tax break, but whether it will help nonprofits is unclear
  43. The AI therapist will see you now: Can chatbots really improve mental health?
  44. Wildfire smoke can make your outdoor workout hazardous to your health – an exercise scientist explains how to gauge the risk
  45. Why recycling solar panels is harder than you might think − an electrical engineer explains
  46. How weather changes cause migraines – a neurologist explains the triggers and what you can do to ease the pain
  47. Dune patterns in California desert hold clues that help researchers map Mars’ shifting sands
  48. Jimmy Swaggart’s rise and fall shaped the landscape of American televangelism
  49. That $20 dress direct from China now costs $30 after Trump closed a tariff loophole – and the US will soon end the ‘de minimis’ exemption for the rest of the world, too
  50. A weakened Iran and Hezbollah gives Lebanon an opening to chart path away from the region’s conflicts − will it be enough?